Silkroad Online Forums

hm.

couple of things.
please, do not see this as a rant.

• the overall sig looks too "space" like for the flower
• i don't like the outer glow you put on your name txt
• im not to fond of the blue c4d that flows within the flower
• the flower does not blend in well
• almost all the effects, i'm not sure why they have been put in
• i see no lightsource

Since you are quite new to making sigs, perhaps it would be wise to try out some of the
tutorials in this section's sticky. The more you practice, the better you get at it.

Keep making them better!

<3

^^gotta agree with cin, some of the c4ds and fx could of been incorporated a lil better. You could tinker with it a bit as it isnt a bad lookin sig at all just a few things pulling it down. Kill the 'Aesthetic' text tho.
Good work

A border and getting rid of the glow around your name would make it look nice

On this one, I don't think a border would make much of a difference, looks fine without one. It looks sloppy, some thrown in c4d's with no distinct flow. As said, the flower isn't blended in very well, could use a quick sharpen here and there.

Text doesn't flow. That outerglow is stomach churning, i'd get rid of that and stay with simple text. Remember, sometimes, less is more in terms of effects. Keep practicing.

i liked everything but the glow around the text

i didnt save as .psd but i think i can try and erase the glow, fill it w/black, then add in the text again. oh and by the way its not a glow lol. i tried to make a box

Save your .psd, I don't see how you guys don't do that. I have 3 seperate folders for alternate versions, final versions, and .psd's. So, start saving your .psd's! <3

oh lol. i didn't know that. my bad well it looked like a glow to me though

well... i dunno what you are talking about... i dont see it there




for the record, you guys, plz plz plz. post a pic of your sig, do not just say see my current sig

why you ask?
for the simple fact that you decide that you are changing the sig, people that come b late dont miss out and also, if you make corrections, its always nice to see the origional



EDIT

sry i guess it just didnt load for me, i see the sig now,

i really like the flower and c4d, its just the outer glow on the text i dislike, gj m8

crap. nevermind i cant do it without having a black splotch on the sig.

looks good but i dont really like the outer glow on the word

wow faiien ~_~ kinda noticed that every post you, you just reword what everyone else wrote. it's already been repeated don't need to repeat it yet again X_X

eh. guess the sig is ruined because of the glow text. and yeah i lose mill will win for sure. over mine anyway ~_~

i dont read what everyone else writes. kinda keeps me honest

thats why i tend to repeat others sometimes

besides if i repeat what everyone else says it doesnt hurt the sig creator in any way O_O...so why should it matter?

yes it does. it annoys me ~_~ nothing against you. anyone who repeats something thats been said over 1000 times (overexaggerating) is really pointing out the obvious. and if it is repeated it makes the sig artist (or me in this case) feel like they're being given a huge hint to go fix the error now


on topic: can someone actually comment instead of critique this? lol. some people commented and yeah thats nice and critique is also appreciated. but would like to see more comments or is it really that bad

Agreed with the points noted by cin, just like to add that there's no real focal in it either..