Which is best?

Geedunk · **Joined:** Jan 2007 **Posts:** 787

Text has been replaced by antirip, although I don't care if it gets ripped >_<.

naljamees51 · **Joined:** Mar 2006 **Posts:** 1054 **Location:** Estonia

w[][]†
im the firs1 who can say what i think XD

ok i think the red is better :wink:

Geedunk · **Joined:** Jan 2007 **Posts:** 787

Oh, and please tell WHY you think so.

0l3n · **Posted:** Tue Jan 30, 2007 2:58 pm

to bright for my taste but yeah the red one apeals more to me.

cant say why

RuYi · **Joined:** Apr 2006 **Posts:** 7145 **Location:** Done.

I like the red version better, it suits the render.

Posei · **Joined:** Dec 2006 **Posts:** 856 **Location:**

Red one for sure. Catches your attention more, good work

XMoshe · **Posted:** Tue Jan 30, 2007 10:16 pm

yep, the red one is way better =)

Rockshmo · **Joined:** May 2006 **Posts:** 1062 **Location:** rehab

Green, cause my favorite color is greeeeeen.

Quyxz · **Posted:** Wed Jan 31, 2007 6:59 am

Its just a matter of taste when u have 2 dif colors with same intensity, I vote both good.

Silver · **Joined:** May 2006 **Posts:** 924 **Location:**

hmm, i think the green one looks nicer.

i just don't like the colour red, nor the shades of it, but it's still nice.

Miyoko · **Joined:** Sep 2006 **Posts:** 267 **Location:**

The colours don't match / flow at all ... The last hue / saturation layer really messes it up, sorry
There's no focal point as well :cry:

And what's with the anti-rip ? o_O Just add your name to it or something, this is pretty confusing you know.

Geedunk · **Joined:** Jan 2007 **Posts:** 787

Miyoko wrote:

The colours don't match / flow at all ... The last hue / saturation layer really messes it up, sorry
There's no focal point as well :cry:

And what's with the anti-rip ? o_O Just add your name to it or something, this is pretty confusing you know.

What about some constructive critism?

- Oh, wait. Your's doesn't flow either.

Miyoko · **Joined:** Sep 2006 **Posts:** 267 **Location:**

My comment wasn't really meant to look bad, you've made really nice signatures but this one just doesn't look right in a way.
What I mean by not flowing is that the last layer just takes over the whole signature, leaving the original colours almost completely out.
Maybe try lowering the last colouring layer's opacity, should come out alot better ^^

The colours you used in your current sig are alot better! Nice flow in them and they don't change the way the signature look that much.
I really like your current signature alot

I choose the red one tho, looks alot better than the green one.

Luoma · **Posted:** Wed Jan 31, 2007 3:38 pm

red one looks nicer, more natural :wink:

lol 0 votes for the blue, although 3 on they're both good

//:Protocol · **Joined:** Apr 2006 **Posts:** 702 **Location:**

I find the render not forcefully applied to your eyes enough, nothing to make it stand out... Just a piece of the background. I.E, No focal point.

It just looks all.. so rushed.. and mhmm.

Like, "I'll just smear some colour here, and I'll leave this patch out, and smear some more colour here."

I'm a very harsh critic.

What you can do to improve the sig is, move the render into the center, it seems like it would look better.

Remove the gaussian blur, everyones using it now, and although it achieves the desired effect, it looks tacky.

And try a bit of smudging.

Also - a light source might be good for yours.

Geedunk · **Joined:** Jan 2007 **Posts:** 787

There is nothing but a render, smudging and filters.

ranger4life · **Joined:** Mar 2006 **Posts:** 2526 **Location:**

as poeple have said red catches poeples atrtention more so yeah

Silkroad Online Forums

Which is best?

Who is online