iPad vs. Toshiba Laptop <Opinions>

Majorharper · **Posted:** Sat Sep 11, 2010 2:38 am

Alright so, I go to college now, and I bring my 2 year old laptop:

To school every single day.

Its 2 years old and im wondering if its worth keeping... (I would sell it to my mom for about 300$)

It doesnt have a video card, its powerful but not that much on battery saver... (sadly)

I would buy an iPad to replace it, since with the new OS I could run more than 1 app at the same time... Which is the first reason why I didn't get the iPad...

Its friggen light as hell, thin as fk, and I can type all my docs. on it no problem. (I would get the 32Gb)

you think i could connect it to my wireles printer? Is it internet (wireless) user friendly? is the word docs compatible/easy to transfer to a pc?

So is the trade worth it? any disappointed / thrived iPad users here?

Pros and cons?

PLEASE NO TROLL :| im serious about this I dont wana waste money...

Thanks guys

VforVendetta · **Joined:** Apr 2007 **Posts:** 1615 **Location:**

If you dont wanna waste money, why even bring up an Apple product?

Goseki · **Joined:** Apr 2008 **Posts:** 3452 **Location:**

VforVendetta wrote:

If you dont wanna waste money, why even bring up an Apple product?

+1

I say wait for the new products similar to the iPad. Cheaper, more compatible, etc.

Ownage · **Joined:** Jul 2009 **Posts:** 1173 **Location:** SwSro!

My dad has one I haven't used it much so couldn't tell you, but I would suggest spending $600 on a refurbished/used laptop with warranty instead it will get you further.

strangelove · **Joined:** Aug 2007 **Posts:** 1255 **Location:** no

If your schoolwork doesn't require much more than a word processor and wireless printing then it won't be a problem for the iPad. You could use the DropBox app (free) for the iPad to auto-sync documents from the iPad to a PC/Mac and save time with transfers (it syncs copies of files on your iPad, DropBox servers, and your desktop). As far as printing goes, there's plenty of apps that allow you to connect to network and wireless printers (there are also a few official apps from the printer manufacturers themselves). If you like the iPad and don't really need powerful computer components, then by all means buy it. If you require something with a bit more versatility, then I'd recommend getting a good netbook and slapping a linux distro on it. They're small, light, and relatively inexpensive.

Azilius · **Joined:** Oct 2006 **Posts:** 4236 **Location:** CS:GO

Are you serious?

You don't want to waste money, then why the hell would you consider something like the iPad which has minimal uses compared to a laptop, and minimal specs as well?

Mirosuke · **Posted:** Sat Sep 11, 2010 5:42 am

Stick to your Toshiba. I think you are bringing excuses with your poor Toshiba to get an iPad. :/

Buddhist · **Posted:** Sat Sep 11, 2010 6:04 am

You can't replace a laptop with an ipad, no matter how old it is, but with a 2 year old laptop you shouldn't have any problem.

emperor3000 · **Joined:** Nov 2007 **Posts:** 1049 **Location:** Home

Laptops > iPads

I am sure you are not really trying to save money considering you would get the 32 gigabyte Apple Women pad.

Either stick with your laptop or get a new laptop.

Toshiharu · **Joined:** Feb 2008 **Posts:** 4222 **Location:** Nowhere

Your laptop is good enough for school. If you want a laptop that's able to run games at minimal specs then go buy <insert information from someone else since I have no idea about laptops>.

Considering that you're selling your old laptop to your mom for $300 I assume it was like $800? It should be good enough for a couple more years until it gets replaced and those specs will be like $200.

DinoNuggets · **Joined:** Jan 2010 **Posts:** 1038 **Location:** Meow

lap top way better than iShit over there.

Hostage · **Posted:** Sat Sep 11, 2010 7:41 am

Fug_Dup wrote:

If your schoolwork doesn't require much more than a word processor and wireless printing then it won't be a problem for the iPad. You could use the DropBox app (free) for the iPad to auto-sync documents from the iPad to a PC/Mac and save time with transfers (it syncs copies of files on your iPad, DropBox servers, and your desktop). As far as printing goes, there's plenty of apps that allow you to connect to network and wireless printers (there are also a few official apps from the printer manufacturers themselves). If you like the iPad and don't really need powerful computer components, then by all means buy it. If you require something with a bit more versatility, then I'd recommend getting a good netbook and slapping a linux distro on it. They're small, light, and relatively inexpensive.

iHate you so much.

Also, I freaking love dropbox! Makes life so much easier. *ring ring* "Hey [My Name] could you re-send me those business card designs?" "They're in dropbox." *goes back to sleep* Too bad I actually have to start going back to the office next week. =(

Fiction · **Posted:** Sat Sep 11, 2010 8:10 am

Goseki wrote:

I say wait for the new products similar to the iPad. Cheaper, more compatible, etc.

I think the product similar to the ipad already came out =P (I know it's been posted before, but still.)

Majorharper · **Posted:** Sat Sep 11, 2010 11:13 am

Toshiharu wrote:

Your laptop is good enough for school. If you want a laptop that's able to run games at minimal specs then go buy <insert information from someone else since I have no idea about laptops>.

Considering that you're selling your old laptop to your mom for $300 I assume it was like $800? It should be good enough for a couple more years until it gets replaced and those specs will be like $200.

My laptop was 950$ in 2008...

Mirosuke wrote:

Stick to your Toshiba. I think you are bringing excuses with your poor Toshiba to get an iPad. :/

Not really, my laptop is heavy, especially that I have to carry around this huge power supply because it wasnt from canada, but from dubai, my adapter is HUGE, takes up a lot of space in my bag... Thats the main reason why I wana get an iPad, its small compact, and battery lasts ages

***Just to clarify***

I meant by wasting my money, is that: I'm ready to make an investment to buy the iPad thats no problem, I have money for it sure, but the thing is as you all said, its dam expensive, but it looks nifty, and its just that after a couple months I don't want to be looking at it saying fu.cking hell...
I don't consider it a ''waste'' of money, if I like the product

Toshiharu wrote:

Your laptop is good enough for school. If you want a laptop that's able to run games at minimal specs then go buy <insert information from someone else since I have no idea about laptops>.

Considering that you're selling your old laptop to your mom for $300 I assume it was like $800? It should be good enough for a couple more years until it gets replaced and those specs will be like $200.

I don't want to play games on my laptop, my desktop is powerful enough for that.

Fug_Dup wrote:

If your schoolwork doesn't require much more than a word processor and wireless printing then it won't be a problem for the iPad. You could use the DropBox app (free) for the iPad to auto-sync documents from the iPad to a PC/Mac and save time with transfers (it syncs copies of files on your iPad, DropBox servers, and your desktop). As far as printing goes, there's plenty of apps that allow you to connect to network and wireless printers (there are also a few official apps from the printer manufacturers themselves). If you like the iPad and don't really need powerful computer components, then by all means buy it. If you require something with a bit more versatility, then I'd recommend getting a good netbook and slapping a linux distro on it. They're small, light, and relatively inexpensive.

Thanks for the info, thats the type of post im looking for..
(im no Apple fan, but this gets me interested)

Thanks guys keep the posts coming, seems like there are apple haters here hehehe

Thats no problem really...

The point is that I just want word processing and powerpoint, I don't need fancy games or some super duper powerful machine, not at all

I want something super light, easy to carry, with very long lasting batteries:)

VforVendetta · **Joined:** Apr 2007 **Posts:** 1615 **Location:**

Master_Of_Puppets it seems like your mind was already made up, so why even ask, why even ask for logical and rational opinions that your laptop is already a lot better than a fad. If you want to look excentric around your buddies than get an iPad, if you want an actual functioning peice of hardware then you already know the choice.

TheDrop · **Joined:** May 2008 **Posts:** 7150 **Location:** uefa2012

For college work, i don't get why anyone would want to buy an ipad unless its only for fun.

I think the ipad costs like 500$ for which you could buy a pretty good new laptop if you don't want to use your old one.

strangelove · **Joined:** Aug 2007 **Posts:** 1255 **Location:** no

Hostage wrote:

iHate you so much.

Also, I freaking love dropbox! Makes life so much easier. *ring ring* "Hey [My Name] could you re-send me those business card designs?" "They're in dropbox." *goes back to sleep* Too bad I actually have to start going back to the office next week. =(

Take that back you.. you fAndroid!

Yeah DropBox is awesome. I use CloudApp more though because it's I don't need syncing as much as file hosting, so that's been a huge timesaver.

VforVendetta wrote:

Master_Of_Puppets it seems like your mind was already made up, so why even ask, why even ask for logical and rational opinions that your laptop is already a lot better than a fad. If you want to look excentric around your buddies than get an iPad, if you want an actual functioning peice of hardware then you already know the choice.

"Better" is subjective and doesn't apply to the needs and requirements of other users, not to mention their own preferences. To completely disregard that and rely on non-objective reasoning is itself illogical and irrational.

Anyway, this is getting silly, moving on!

Master_of_Puppets wrote:

Thanks for the info, thats the type of post im looking for..
(im no Apple fan, but this gets me interested)

Thanks guys keep the posts coming, seems like there are apple haters here hehehe

Thats no problem really...

The point is that I just want word processing and powerpoint, I don't need fancy games or some super duper powerful machine, not at all

I want something super light, easy to carry, with very long lasting batteries:)

The official Apple suite for the iPad (iWork for iPad, derp) is really good for getting those things done. iWork is composed of a word processor (Pages), presentation creator (Keynote), and spreadsheet maker (Numbers). There's a bunch of videos of application features on the Apple site if you want more info.

http://www.apple.com/ipad/guided-tours/

Now here's the kicker, and most likely the deal breaker. While the 3 apps can easily import many file types, the official exporting tool is complete crap. 'Keynote' and 'Numbers' do not support exporting documents to Office suite formats, which might be an issue. They support exporting as PDF files or sending files via email, and even using an online service for viewing the files. There might be a third-party solution to that, and I haven't really looked into it, but the iWork suite is still just a 1.0 release so maybe an official solution would be available in later updates. 'Pages' does support exporting to .doc so that's not an issue.

Your other solution as I said is to buy a good netbook. They're about the price of an iPad or less and they're neat little devices for on-the-go computing. They usually come pre-installed with a slimmed down version of Win7 (or the full OS on more powerful ones) although I prefer the Linux-based JoliCloud myself.

Hope that helps.

- Sent from my iPad :sohappy:

(but not really)

Ownage · **Joined:** Jul 2009 **Posts:** 1173 **Location:** SwSro!

Netbooks are a lot cheaper, an ipad would cost like $600? While you can find a ton of netbooks in the $200-400 range.

McLovin1t · **Joined:** Apr 2008 **Posts:** 1825 **Location:**

Azilius wrote:

Are you serious?

You don't want to waste money, then why the hell would you consider something like the iPad which has minimal uses compared to a laptop, and minimal specs as well?

Yeah this.
Get a decent netbook laptop, like the small ones, or get another laptop from like cyberpower or ibuypower that has great specs, and a pretty low price. Those brand names are usually way overpriced.

vietxboy911 · **Joined:** Jul 2007 **Posts:** 3236 **Location:**

Ownage wrote:

Netbooks are a lot cheaper, an ipad would cost like $600? While you can find a ton of netbooks in the $200-400 range.

yeah, your better off getting one of these in the long run. I think the iPad is great, but for more entertainment purposes. Plus, people might want to rob you :roll:

Vuesters92 · **Joined:** May 2007 **Posts:** 536 **Location:**

just get cheap 100-200$ laptop if you only want it for school work. these 100-200$ laptop are very small and light weight(about 3/4 the size of the laptop u already own). althogh the specs are not great it is more than enough to do school work. I personally don't think there is a good use for the ipad since there are notebooks around already, and you can also type faster on a notebook keyboard than ipad keys. If you want to own a apple product then check out thier mp3 players(a.k.a ipods).

Azilius · **Joined:** Oct 2006 **Posts:** 4236 **Location:** CS:GO

Master_of_Puppets wrote:

***Just to clarify***

I meant by wasting my money, is that: I'm ready to make an investment to buy the iPad thats no problem, I have money for it sure, but the thing is as you all said, its dam expensive, but it looks nifty, and its just that after a couple months I don't want to be looking at it saying fu.cking hell...
I don't consider it a ''waste'' of money, if I like the product

&

Think logically. Get a laptop or a netbook.

Mirosuke · **Posted:** Sat Sep 11, 2010 7:31 pm

I remember someone said...
Why bothering asking if you already made a decision?
Pretty much you will looking for anyone post that support the iPad (which are few) so, at the end, it's up to you. it's your money.
:o

Majorharper · **Posted:** Sat Sep 11, 2010 8:35 pm

Hmmm anyone here know of a netbook / laptop w/e that can last 10hours of run time (while doing stuff, not just idle) and that weighs less than 1 kilo? if so PLEASE tell me, ima buy it NAO!

Thats the main reason for the iPad really, and this post is 100% serious, if anyone knows a brand that makes them, and dont lag, please tell me, i'll buy it.

As I mentioned, im not an apple fan at all, so stop bashing me for that, I have previously owned an iPod U2 edition, sold it to my dad cuz i didnt like it so yeah, im lookin into the iPad because of lightweight and battery life...

Azilius · **Joined:** Oct 2006 **Posts:** 4236 **Location:** CS:GO

Lag? Lag how? A laptop shouldn't "lag" doing the exact same things an iPad would do.

Regardless of that, there ARE laptops that are lightweight, have less "lag" than the iPad, have long battery life AND cost around the same price or less. You're being ignorant and falling for Apples advertising. But hey that's your choice, there have been many posts here telling you what's right.

http://www.newegg.ca/Product/Product.as ... 6834220681
http://www.newegg.ca/Product/Product.as ... 6834220651
http://www.newegg.ca/Product/Product.as ... 4157345CVF

All 3 less than 3 pounds. A kilogram is about 2.2 pounds. Each has 250gb HDD and a processor that is technically better than the A4 processor.

That took TWO minutes of searching. :palm:

Majorharper · **Posted:** Sat Sep 11, 2010 10:31 pm

Azilius wrote:

Lag? Lag how? A laptop shouldn't "lag" doing the exact same things an iPad would do.

Regardless of that, there ARE laptops that are lightweight, have less "lag" than the iPad, have long battery life AND cost around the same price or less. You're being ignorant and falling for Apples advertising. But hey that's your choice, there have been many posts here telling you what's right.

http://www.newegg.ca/Product/Product.as ... 6834220681
http://www.newegg.ca/Product/Product.as ... 6834220651
http://www.newegg.ca/Product/Product.as ... 4157345CVF

All 3 less than 3 pounds. A kilogram is about 2.2 pounds. Each has 250gb HDD and a processor that is technically better than the A4 processor.

That took TWO minutes of searching. :palm:

Thanks i'll have a look at them when I have time, sorry for being busy, anyways thanks for the replies i'll have a look at some more laptops, and other suggestiongs are appreciated..

Thanks

TheDrop · **Joined:** May 2008 **Posts:** 7150 **Location:** uefa2012

Master_of_Puppets wrote:

Hmmm anyone here know of a netbook / laptop w/e that can last 10hours of run time (while doing stuff, not just idle) and that weighs less than 1 kilo? if so PLEASE tell me, ima buy it NAO!

Thats the main reason for the iPad really, and this post is 100% serious, if anyone knows a brand that makes them, and dont lag, please tell me, i'll buy it.

As I mentioned, im not an apple fan at all, so stop bashing me for that, I have previously owned an iPod U2 edition, sold it to my dad cuz i didnt like it so yeah, im lookin into the iPad because of lightweight and battery life...

So this is how the thread is going

You ask for advice on whether you should keep your laptop or buy a ipad

most people tell you keep your laptop since its cheaper than the ipad, its for college, and iPads are only for entertainment for the like the first few weeks and then they get old.

you say your toshiba is lame etc

Others say you can get a new laptop for much cheaper than an ipad

you say ipad is the shitz and looks nifty.

If you already made up your mind on getting an iPad, then why create a thread about it?

Love · **Joined:** Nov 2007 **Posts:** 5336 **Location:**

The answer is quite obvious ... buy a laptop with good battery life, how is this even a question ?

Toshiharu · **Joined:** Feb 2008 **Posts:** 4222 **Location:** Nowhere

Master_of_Puppets wrote:

Toshiharu wrote:

Your laptop is good enough for school. If you want a laptop that's able to run games at minimal specs then go buy <insert information from someone else since I have no idea about laptops>.

Considering that you're selling your old laptop to your mom for $300 I assume it was like $800? It should be good enough for a couple more years until it gets replaced and those specs will be like $200.

My laptop was 950$ in 2008...

Toshiharu wrote:

Your laptop is good enough for school. If you want a laptop that's able to run games at minimal specs then go buy <insert information from someone else since I have no idea about laptops>.

Considering that you're selling your old laptop to your mom for $300 I assume it was like $800? It should be good enough for a couple more years until it gets replaced and those specs will be like $200.

I don't want to play games on my laptop, my desktop is powerful enough for that.

Your laptop shouldn't be lagging in any way. You probably have installed too much garbage. Reformat it, get off Vista, and it'll be fine for everything. My $200 laptop runs without any 'lag'. Only lag I get is starting up programs that need a bit more resource than the usual stuff.

As mentioned you have your mindset on getting the iPad regardless of what we tell you. I guess I'm done here.

Ownage · **Joined:** Jul 2009 **Posts:** 1173 **Location:** SwSro!

http://www.bestbuy.com/site/Samsung+-+N ... 8163687501

It has upto 7hours battery life, which is a bit shorter then you want but I don't think you will find many at 10hours.

Silkroad Online Forums

iPad vs. Toshiba Laptop <Opinions>

Who is online