Better Japanese Visual Kei/ Rock band out of these two?

Crowley · **Posted:** Tue Mar 24, 2009 6:53 am

Which one out of these two do you think is better?

ACID
Code: Select all

Abingdon Boys School
Code: Select all

Personally I think ACID is better. Junpei (the singer) of ACID has a really unique voice, it's different but still really good. I think ACID is one of the best Japanese Visual Kei bands, they're just...Let's say "undiscovered". Too bad the singer had to retire

As for Abingdon Boys School the singer is also really good. You have to take into account that they're really young and his voice probably hasn't fully developed yet though :\ However their songs don't get much better than INNOCENT SORROW whereas ACID has many good songs.

Also tell me what you think about ACID. Everyone that I have recommended them to think that they're really bad. I guess they just can't appreciate something "different".

whorelock · **Joined:** Feb 2008 **Posts:** 307 **Location:**

ehh i voted for the second one the first guy sounds like hes whining

I_R_Powerpuff · **Joined:** Jul 2008 **Posts:** 1158 **Location:** IRL

Tsume wrote:

Which one out of these two do you think is better?

Abingdon Boys School
Code: Select all

NobleHunter · **Posted:** Wed Mar 25, 2009 1:24 pm

Both suck pretty bad

Grimjaw · **Posted:** Wed Mar 25, 2009 2:40 pm

Abingdon Boys School.

kabuki · **Posted:** Wed Mar 25, 2009 5:23 pm

To me its the opposite of what you said... the first guy seems to have a more whiney, boy-like voice than the 2nd guy and also the first guy sounds like a typical emo singer IMO. The 2nd guy seems to have a more developed voice. =\ If I had to choose, I'd say 2nd one is better.

Crowley · **Posted:** Thu Mar 26, 2009 3:34 am

kabuki wrote:

To me its the opposite of what you said... the first guy seems to have a more whiney, boy-like voice than the 2nd guy and also the first guy sounds like a typical emo singer IMO. The 2nd guy seems to have a more developed voice. =\ If I had to choose, I'd say 2nd one is better.

What about Live?...

ACID
Code: Select all

Abingdon Boys School
Code: Select all

whorelock · **Joined:** Feb 2008 **Posts:** 307 **Location:**

kabuki wrote:

To me its the opposite of what you said... the first guy seems to have a more whiney, boy-like voice than the 2nd guy and also the first guy sounds like a typical emo singer IMO. The 2nd guy seems to have a more developed voice. =\ If I had to choose, I'd say 2nd one is better.

that is what i said not opposite

kabuki · **Posted:** Thu Mar 26, 2009 4:12 pm

whorelock wrote:

kabuki wrote:

To me its the opposite of what you said... the first guy seems to have a more whiney, boy-like voice than the 2nd guy and also the first guy sounds like a typical emo singer IMO. The 2nd guy seems to have a more developed voice. =\ If I had to choose, I'd say 2nd one is better.

that is what i said not opposite

I was not talking to you... O_O it was meant for the thread starter.

Tsume wrote:

kabuki wrote:

To me its the opposite of what you said... the first guy seems to have a more whiney, boy-like voice than the 2nd guy and also the first guy sounds like a typical emo singer IMO. The 2nd guy seems to have a more developed voice. =\ If I had to choose, I'd say 2nd one is better.

What about Live?...

Spoiler!

I still think the 2nd one is better although ACID live is better than the actual recording. But you really don't need other peoples opinion to like a certain band, you like the first better so that's all that should matter.

Miguez · **Joined:** Nov 2008 **Posts:** 5003 **Location:**

I don't know..

Lyrics are very important to me, and since I don't understand what they're saying, I can't really say wich one is better.

IceCrash · **Posted:** Thu Mar 26, 2009 11:14 pm

Aqua Timez, best band
Gackt, best indivudual
/thread

Reise · **Joined:** May 2006 **Posts:** 6650 **Location:**

I voted both suck, but I'm biased as I hate all Japanese music.

It makes my ears bleed.

And Gackt is a cross-dressing queen. Not cool, bro.

Sacchin · **Joined:** Sep 2007 **Posts:** 2797

ABS ftw <3

I even have their old stuff "TM Revolution" ^^

Silkroad Online Forums

Better Japanese Visual Kei/ Rock band out of these two?

Who is online