Silkroad Online Forums

for a friend.

just so you know, the theme was Carrots, since his forum
name on an other forum is carrot. well IMO carrots are
boring, so i had to try my best to make it into something
fun.

ok so first, think of carrots.

then, click spoiler and see if it's what you expected.

last, comment on it. i put most effort in coming up with
something, so i expect some comments on lighting and such ;]

LOL, love it. So silly.

9/10

love it save the outline on the hands.

i dont agree with Nantosh, i think the outlines in the hands are v important for the feeling you wanna transmit, i think the lighting is good, only thing is , try to give it a lil bit more motion on the right hand, to make it feel like he's really punching something, i alredy feel it but i think u could improve in that.
And tbh i'm not that great fan of things like u did on the right of the sig, but thats personal taste i think..
I don't like the text, i think it'd be good if u did it like, each color of the bg a letter is in touch with, make it so that letter is in a colour that goes well with the one in the bg, try that, maybe it could result on something nice, dunno. Maybe try to find a middle composition in terms of colours for it to be more appealing, cause i find the text quite boring tbh.
Anyways, i really like the sig tho, it's very funny, and creative, looks like u had a good idea and put some time into it, maybe with some lil adjustments it can become even better, idk.
You know i'm not that great, but since u posted the way u did, i really felt like trying to give a propper comment, might help u with something, most likely wont, but oh well ^^
Gj mate

You need text that pops for those kinda sigs. Since its so simple, text should make a bigger % of the tag. And the lighting colours, u need to use those nice bg colours more. Lighting doesnt have to be limited to black and white.

And the pixelly outline of his hands ruin the depth. But nice work anyways. kiu